Exploding Mortgages V

From Billmon writing about the housing bubble:

“But what makes things different — and potentially more exciting — this time around are the gaudy new financing gimmicks Kevin mentions: no money down loans, interest-only mortgages, ARMs that reset to truly usurious rates, etc. If and when these loans blow up, and they will, it could leave many home “owners” with no alternative but to sell and sell quickly — or simply mail the keys back to the bank.”

Who is responsible for this situation?

In our popular culture, the responsibility will get placed largely on the customer – on individuals who signed up for exploding mortgages.

Caveat emptor — buyer beware — has a long and important history and some of the responsibility always should lie with the customer.

But in a world where place still fostered shared values, individuals were much more likely to be bouyed in their choices by the shared wisdom of extended yet present family and neighbors who lived nearby and participated meaningfully in their shared lives. Folks would not let folks sign up for exploding mortgages.

Most of us no longer live in a world of places. We live in a world of markets, networks, organizations, friends and family. In this new world, an extraordinary amount of responsibility for the safety, sanity and sustainability of our society rests with organizations — because organizations are where we come together for an experience of community — of thick we’s — that allow us to ask and answer: What difference do we wish to make — together — to the world we live in?

Our long history of markets in a world of places does not always serve us best in answering this. The singularity of the profit motive arose in a world of places because place itself fostered shared values that moderated the effects of businesses operating out of self-interest. Today, our most prevalent shared values – that is, predictable patterns of belief and behavior — happen because of markets, networks and organizations — not places. Of these, organizations are the most important: they set the tone of what matters, of what we really stand for.

While undertandable from a standpoint of history, what most private sector organizations really stand for is profit. But, that is neither sustainable nor sufficient in our new world. It has led, for example, to widespread and entrenched shareholder value fundamentalism every bit as virulent as religious fundamentalism. That, in turn, leads to financial institutions, realtors, mortgage brokers, speculators and others who — as thick we’s — make it their shared purpose to build profits and shareholder value at any cost without regard for other values.

That, in turn, leads to exploding mortgages.

Responsibiity? Customers? Yes, somewhat.

The core responsibility lies however with the folks who show up to work every day in companies that create and sell exploding mortgages. And until a critical mass of employees and executives of those companies figure out they are responsible for the horrendous things happening to their ‘customers’ — and their customers’ families and children — we will continue to move blindly and recklessly through a world we refuse to take responsibility for.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *